Project constraints in software development
Last updated: January 22, 2024 Read in fullscreen view
Recommended for you
- 02 Nov 2023
Differences between software walkthrough, review, and inspection - 02 Nov 2021 What is Terms of Reference (ToR)?
- 18 Oct 2021 Key Elements to Ramping Up a Large Team
- 15 Feb 2024 What is a Cut-Over in Software Development?
- 03 Apr 2022 Microsoft Solutions Framework (MSF)
The Theory of Constraints (TOC) is a management philosophy developed by Eliyahu M. Goldratt. It focuses on identifying and improving the most critical constraint that limits the overall performance of a system, with the goal of maximizing throughput and achieving organizational goals. While TOC originated in the manufacturing industry, its principles can be applied to various domains, including software development.
“No chain can ever be stronger than it’s weakest link.”
In the context of software development, the Theory of Constraints can be applied to identify and address bottlenecks that hinder the overall efficiency and effectiveness of the development process.
Identifying the constraint
TOC encourages teams to identify the most significant constraint that limits the flow of work in the development process. In software development, this constraint can vary, such as limited development resources, slow feedback loops, or dependencies on external systems. By identifying and focusing on the constraint, teams can prioritize their efforts and allocate resources accordingly.
“Fast, Cheap, and Good… pick two. If it’s Fast and Cheap, it won’t be Good; If it’s Cheap and Good, it won’t be Fast. If it’s Fast and Good, it won’t be Cheap. So pick two to live by.”
-Jim Jarmusch
Exploiting the constraint
Once the constraint is identified, TOC suggests exploiting it by maximizing its utilization. In software development, this means ensuring that the constrained resource, such as a specialized developer or a specific tool, is used to its full potential. By optimizing the utilization of the constraint, teams can increase the overall throughput of the development process.
Project Constraint Examples by Type and Industry
In this chart, you’ll find examples of each of the six main types of constraints in the construction, IT, and marketing industries.
| Construction | IT | Marketing | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Time | The team must complete construction on the building before the client opens their new store location. | The team must complete a new app before its debut at an upcoming conference. | Marketing materials must be in the mail to customers before Labor Day for a Labor Day sale. |
| Cost | The construction team must stay within an approved budget for materials and labor. | The budget includes money for research, development, and testing. | The budget includes research, design, printing, and mailing. |
| Scope | The building plans specify what the construction team needs to build and what will be built elsewhere. | The app is a supplement to an existing product, so it must integrate with and augment the experience of that product. | The campaign includes 400 flyers delivered by mail to addresses within one mile of the store one week before Labor Day. |
| Quality | Construction must meet standards of quality in order to pass inspection and fulfill the client’s expectations. | The app must perform without bugs on all platforms. | Flyers must be visually appealing and printed on high-quality glossy cardstock that can survive shipping. |
| Resources | This project requires building materials, construction software, vehicles, and labor. | This project requires one lead and three junior developers, a UX designer, all necessary software, and up-to-date hardware. | This project requires designers and writers, printers and ink, glossy cardstock, postage, and a list of local addresses. |
| Risks | Risks include failed inspections, schedule changes caused by shipping delays, and low availability of laborers. | Risks include schedule delays, hardware and memory failures, and difficulties formatting the app on multiple platforms. | Risks include mail delays and poor print quality. |
How Do Project Constraints Affect Each Other?
When you change one project constraint, it will often impact the others. For instance, if a budget decreases, project managers will need to adjust the resources and timeline. Consider all constraints to ensure that projects are successful.
A good project manager knows how to stay within project constraints, but they also know when they can exceed them. The triple constraint triangle is one of the best examples. When scope increases, so must cost and time to balance it. In this scenario, if these constraints are not balanced, the project will cost more, take longer, and decrease in quality.
Subordinating non-constraints
TOC advises subordinating non-constraints to the constraint, meaning that other elements in the development process should align their performance to support the constraint’s requirements. For example, if the constraint is the development team’s productivity, non-constraints such as testing or documentation should adapt their processes to enable faster development cycles.
Continuous improvement
TOC emphasizes the importance of continuous improvement. In software development, this translates to regularly analyzing the system, identifying new constraints, and taking steps to address them. By constantly refining the development process, teams can optimize the flow of work and achieve better overall outcomes.
Applying the Theory of Constraints in software development helps teams focus their efforts on the critical aspects that limit productivity and effectiveness. By identifying and resolving constraints, organizations can improve their development processes, reduce lead times, enhance quality, and ultimately deliver software more efficiently.
Here are some aspects to consider:
- System monitoring: Establish a system of monitoring and measurement to gather data and insights about the development process. This can include metrics such as lead time, cycle time, throughput, defect rates, customer satisfaction, and resource utilization. Regularly analyze this data to identify patterns, trends, and potential areas of improvement.
- Feedback loops: Encourage feedback from stakeholders, including developers, product managers, product designers, and end-users. Their insights can provide valuable perspectives on pain points, challenges, and opportunities for improvement. Actively seek feedback through retrospectives, surveys, or regular check-ins to identify areas that need attention.
- Root cause analysis: When constraints or issues arise, conduct root cause analysis to identify the underlying causes. Apply techniques such as the “5 Whys” or fishbone diagrams to dig deeper and uncover the fundamental reasons behind constraints. Understanding the root causes helps in developing effective solutions that address the core issues.
- Experimentation and innovation: Foster a culture of experimentation and innovation within the development team. Encourage individuals to try new approaches, tools, or techniques that could potentially alleviate constraints or improve processes. Embrace a mindset of continuous learning and encourage knowledge sharing within the team.
- Agile and iterative approach: Adopt an agile and iterative approach to software development, such as Scrum or Kanban. These methodologies inherently emphasize regular reflection, adaptation, and improvement. Conduct frequent retrospectives to assess the effectiveness of the development process and identify areas for refinement.
- Collaborative problem-solving: Encourage collaborative problem-solving within the development team. Empower team members to actively participate in the identification and resolution of constraints. Leverage their diverse skills and perspectives to collectively brainstorm solutions and implement improvements.
- Continuous learning and skill development: Invest in the ongoing learning and skill development of the development team. Provide opportunities for training, workshops, conferences, or knowledge-sharing sessions. By enhancing the skills and knowledge of the team members, you can tackle constraints more effectively and drive continuous improvement.
By embracing a mindset of continuous improvement, software development teams can incrementally refine their processes, address emerging constraints, and optimize their overall performance. The focus should be on fostering a culture of learning, collaboration, and innovation, where everyone is empowered to contribute to the ongoing improvement efforts.
Sources:
- https://www.smartsheet.com/content/project-constraints
- https://mikecarruego.medium.com/the-theory-of-constraints-in-software-development-7e37cb0911db
- https://www.goodfirms.co/blog/mastering-project-management-constraints-in-software-development
Explore more on these topics
Guest Blogging: The Definitive Guide
